Sea Goat

by Taylor Sykes

“Beneath the tides of time and space—strange fish are swimming.” 

—Charles Berlitz’s World of Strange Phenomena

 

Mountains-to-sea, mountains-to-sea, Glenn was humming to herself at the start of the journey from the Blue Ridge Mountains to the Outer Banks. Why was it only mountains-to-sea, she wondered, and never the reverse? Next to her in the passenger’s seat, Kevin palmed the dashboard with both hands as the highway curved, then curved again. Glenn knew that he wanted her to slow down, but she was too thirsty for the coastline, the seabirds, the water, for the descent down the mountain and back to the place where life came from. 

In the back seat their golden retriever, MJ, was focused on the open sliver of sunroof. MJ preferred car rides to almost every other pleasure she knew, but she’d never been to the ocean before.

An hour into the drive the radio went off about the hurricane. 

“Did you get trip insurance?” Kevin asked. 

“I did.” 

“Should we be turning back?” 

“It’s just a storm.” 

“A tropical storm. With the promise of becoming a hurricane.” 

“You say promise, I say potential. Not definite.” 

“Since when are promises definite?” 

Glenn laughed and switched the radio station. Meanwhile MJ kept on snorting into the wind, her dark eyes wild and watering. 

It always took Glenn by surprise how quickly the mountains lost their dominance over the landscape. Just as the repetitive nature of the drive was settling in, the landscape shifted again. Now they were driving along quieter low-country roads, where long fences of rainwater separated properties. The air became heavy and humid, and even the trees seemed bogged down by the burden of their own foliage. Ahead in the distance the sky was undeniable. 

“The hurricane can’t be here yet,” Glenn said, nodding at the navy-blue blanket of sky. 

For a while they were alone on the road, but as they approached the coast, a steady procession appeared. All heading in the opposite direction. 

Kevin adjusted his glasses. “Quite the mass exodus.”

“It’s a little early to be evacuating, don’t you think?” 

In response a bolt of lightning branched through the sky, heralding a theatrical curtain of rain to crash down thick and resolute. Kevin jumped in his seat, MJ voiced her concerns, and Glenn almost drove them all off the road.  

“Hey!” she shouted. “Don’t do that!”

Just breathe, drive straight, drive steady, Glenn told herself. This storm had absolutely nothing to do with what wind was currently off the coast of somewhere very south of here . . . 

Suddenly Kevin sat up straighter in his seat. “Slow down a little bit. There’s a sign up ahead.”

 Glenn squinted through the rain. ALLIGATOR RIVER BRIDGE.

She took a deep breath as though preparing to dive underwater. 

Before the bridge there had at least been trees to mask the storm; now flashes of lightning came from all sides, brilliant bursts of many-pronged pitchforks crashing down to pierce the river. She heard Kevin say something about the tires, how the rubber was supposed to protect you. Like a well-timed joke, an alert went off in the car. LOW TIRE PRESSURE. MJ started to whine. 

“Oh, honey,” Glenn whined back. “It’s okay, it’s all okay. Kevin, comfort her.” 

But Kevin did not turn around. Instead he pointed a shaky finger ahead.

Glenn saw the red shadow of another car. A car on pause in the middle of the bridge. 

“Why is this person stopped?” she asked, a new panic threading through her. 

“I think you should just go around.” Kevin’s suggestion was so soft she could hardly hear him over the metallic roar overhead.

“Go around? I can’t even see around. What if the driver is stopped for a reason? What if the bridge is flooded? What if they know something we don’t?” 

Another car approached from behind and honked twice. MJ was fully quaking now, whimpering at the roof of the car. Glenn grimaced and directed the car to the left lane. As far as she could see, which was not far at all, there were no other drivers crossing. 

As they passed the stalled car, Kevin said, “It’s a couple. Man in the driver’s seat, woman in the passenger’s. They’re fighting, throwing their hands in the air. Would you say that this is the worst possible place for a lovers’ quarrel?” 

“That is so unbelievably dangerous.” 

In the rearview she watched as the car behind also passed the fighting couple. 

Strangers, Glenn thought, strangers and their carelessness for other strangers. At least the rain was dwindling along with her adrenaline. She felt low on pressure, too, like the tires. 

Making it to the small harbor town at last, Glenn pulled over at what appeared to be the one and only grocery store. She ran inside to stock up on some last-minute beach necessities, and she was carrying a case of beer toward the front of the store when the door of the market crashed open. A little redheaded girl in a yellow bathing suit had kicked open the glass panel with startling enthusiasm, a woman with matching red hair trailing a few steps behind. 

As soon as she entered, the woman caught Glenn’s eye. 

“Hey,” she said from across the aisle, “did you see that idiot on the road? I was right behind you.” 

Glenn stared for a moment, adjusting the alcohol in her arms. 

“Saw your car out front. Your husband’s fiddling with the tires. Cute dog. Looks like a strong swimmer.” 

“Right,” Glenn said, shaking her head. “It was very bizarre. I was driving and it kind of freaked me out.” 

“Idiot kid.” The woman rolled her eyes, moving past Glenn to the refrigerators. 

For a second Glenn wondered whether she was speaking in reference to her own child. “Excuse me?” 

“There was some kid parked in that car,” the woman called from the back. “Didn’t you see?” 

“No, I didn’t, actually. My partner looked, though, and he said it was a couple.” 

The woman returned to the front of the store with the same case of beer as Glenn. Even at a distance, Glenn could smell her body odor, but it smelled good, both sour and sweet like a dog’s breath.

 Leaving cash on the counter, the woman turned to Glenn. “Wasn’t a couple. It was some teenage boy fooling around.” 

Glenn noticed that the little girl had glitter all over her face. That and some smudged chocolate around her mouth gave her the appearance of a muddy mermaid.  

Not sure what else to add, Glenn shrugged. “Hey, at least we made it.” 

“Made it?” the woman mocked, ushering her daughter with a sandaled foot. “Ha.” 

Outside, the rain had all but ceased. Kevin had already refilled the tires, let the dog out, and was leaning against the driver’s side door with his hands in his pockets. 

“You’re going to drive?” she asked, passing him the case of beer. 

“LandShark—nice,” he laughed. “And yeah, I thought I’d take this last leg. Or toe.” 

Glenn kissed him. “How’s MJ?” 

The dog had her head out the window and was making a face that said, What’s the holdup? 

“A little excited, maybe. But she seems fine.” 

Glenn kissed the dog too and walked to the other side of the car. Inhaling the combination of sand and surf and fresh rain in the air, she felt relieved that their rental house was on a part of the harbor without any nearby neighbors. Maybe tomorrow they wouldn’t even need to go into town. Maybe they wouldn’t see another soul. 

***

The way the road swept back and forth in a slanted cursive was hypnotizing to Glenn. For ten miles they drove along the sound. It was a quiet road, at first hosting a few cozy bungalows, then some grander houses all clustered together, and then no homes at all, just harsh and naked trees with branches shooting out in all directions like hand-drawn stars. The grasses were high, and murky water pooled in the grooves along the side of the road. Not a single other car passed. Even the sky was silent now, no longer bearing any storm clouds. Instead it maintained a static shade of gray. 

“Spooky,” Kevin said, also looking at the sky. “Are you sure the house is out here?” 

“I’m sure. There should be a dirt road coming.” 

Soon enough there were garbage cans, some mailboxes, signs of life. Then a break in the starry trees and, for the first time in miles, another home. This house was on the grander side of the scale, boasting three decks, a manicured lawn, and a handsome dock extending into the sound. Not to mention the boat. 

“This can’t be the house,” Kevin laughed. 

“In our dreams. Keep going.” 

As they bumped along a little farther, the aggravated waves seemed to extend right up to the road. Tall beach grasses and chunks of concrete were the only barriers between the road and the sound. Ahead the little house was becoming visible. A dark point in the dim. 

Glenn reached over to rub the back of Kevin’s neck, playing with his sandy hair. This house was a gift she’d given herself. Because it was there, there in this house, that she would write something—a solitary story—for the first time in months. No hurricane could stop her. 

The long driveway led to an elevated log cabin at the edge of the water. Kevin adjusted behind the steering wheel, looking impressed. Behind the house the sound was right there, complete with a little sandy beach, a stone firepit, and a slightly less charismatic dock than the neighbor’s. 

“Well, shit,” Kevin said, turning off the car.

She brightened. “What do you think, MJ?” 

Free from the back seat, MJ pranced around the yard, tormenting the dozens of dragonflies that dove through the tall grass. 

Glenn carried their first round of belongings up the deck stairs. Nudging inside the screened-in porch, she looked for the house key under the dolphin statue as described, but instead she found the house already unlocked. The door was wide open, the key in the handle, no dolphin in sight. She called out to Kevin, but he was investigating the water with MJ. She entered anyway.

Inside she took in the cabin’s vaulted ceiling, the wood-burning stove, and the four full-length windows along the eastern wall. There was a dining room table in front of the windows where daydreamers could sit and stare. The living room took up the center of the space, with an open kitchen off to the side. From the bedroom the view was entirely waves upon waves. It looked like if she climbed out the window, she’d fall right into those waves.

Later that night, Glenn struggled to sleep in the new environment. During nighttime hours she was often at the mercy of her mind’s eye and its ever-spinning reel. Tonight she reviewed the most impactful scenes from earlier in the day. The mountain drive, the storm, the alligator bridge, the inexplicably parked car, and then—

“Kevin!” she whispered, propping herself up on her elbow. 

“Hmm?” 

Kevin never struggled to fall asleep. Below she could hear MJ yipping through her dragonfly dreams. 

“At the grocery store earlier, I spoke to the woman who was in the car behind us on the bridge. She said there was a teenager in the parked car, not a couple. You said it was a couple. She said it was a teenager. Doesn’t that seem odd?” 

Kevin rolled over to face her but kept his eyes closed. “I guess she just got it wrong.” 

“She was pretty confident. Very confident, actually.” 

“Well, it was definitely a couple.” 

“You’re sure?” 

Now his eyes were open. “I don’t know why it matters, but yes, I’m sure.” 

“It doesn’t matter, it doesn’t. Good night.” 

As soon as she was settled, Kevin draped an arm around her waist and kissed her shoulder. “I hope you sleep the sleep of a thousand sleeps,” he said.

Glenn smiled into her pillow. “A thousand sleeps with the whales.” 

***

Pulled by water and the promise of light, Glenn woke before dawn. She rose quietly, leaving Kevin undisturbed but not MJ, who seized the opportunity to take up the free space on the bed. Fine, stay behind, Glenn thought. How many moments alone does a person have? 

She wandered from the bedroom to the back porch in bare feet, eager to dip her toes and calves into the sound. What she really wanted was to strip off her nightgown and swim, but Kevin had already cautioned against that exact impulse. As a couple, they were so good at reading each other’s minds and anticipating actions that they could both quell or incite a reaction before it arrived. At every stage, every mile marker, even in their lives before, it was clear they’d always been on the same trajectory, bound for the same destination. They were similar in so many ways, but in this they were different: Glenn was a swimmer and Kevin was not. 

“Sharks, muscle cramps, whatever,” he’d said back at home. “Swimming alone, especially at night or in the morning . . .” As she started to protest, he spoke plainly. “Swim all you want, just swim where I can see you.”

His request was fair enough. She needed to respect that, at least on the first dawn. 

The sky was pale purple, brightening to blue. The waves were the same. The sun rose, but mostly Glenn watched the water and waited for it to speak, to reveal a truth, spit out a pearl, or wash up a message. The sea carried secrets Glenn wanted to share. 

“Speak to me,” she asked of the chilled expanse in which she stood, and to the colder ocean beyond the banks. Her nightgown soaked to the thighs, and all she wanted was to sink further. 

The day’s potent sunshine made it hard to accept that a hurricane was about to arrive. By midafternoon the wind was high, and what few clouds there were moved like swift fish in the sky. Kevin’s hair curled in the humidity; Glenn’s hair stayed damp all day. Anytime it started to dry, she swam out to the end of the dock. That’s where she was now and would remain so long as she could tread water. Shouting distance away, Kevin stood between tufts of tall grass with his shirt unbuttoned. Watching him throw the ball into the water for MJ, Glenn recognized the same enthusiastic smile on both of their faces. 

With her toes pointed and her back arched, Glenn was more graceful in the water than she could ever hope to be on land. In an instant she switched from treading to floating until it felt like the water was holding her aloft and a nap was fathomable. Her ear canals flooded. Though she was watching the seagulls above, all she heard was the shuddering silence below. After a while she thought the ocean warbled her name, but it was only Kevin calling her back to shore.

Glenn had always relished the reluctance of getting out of the water, her feet dragging in the sand, the waves pulling her back, the air itself a chilly affront. The way the water invited her to stay. Even after a short swim her body was shivering with electricity, and as she stood taller in the water, the hair on her arms rose to sharp peaks. 

“What’s wrong?” she asked.

“Just got a notification that Ocracoke Island is being evacuated, along with parts of Southern Shores.” 

“That makes sense.” Glenn lifted a hand to shield her eyes. “They’re more exposed down there.” 

Kevin seemed tentative. “We’re pretty exposed here too. Let’s just keep our eye on it.” 

“Our eye?” 

“We don’t want to wait until it’s too late to make a decision.” 

“What if it’s already too late?” she gasped. “What if the decision has already been made for us?” 

Kevin laughed, but she continued to pick up waves of uncertainty from him. His stress may as well have been her own, a shared empathy that flowed both ways. As soon as the radio went off in the car, he would’ve turned back. She was sure of that. Had she not been there to charge forward, he would’ve turned back. And since neither of them was particularly keen on the prospect of retreat, Kevin wouldn’t have called it that—turning back—because for him it was a redirection, a shift in course. For her, the beach house was the only course. She meant what she said. It was already too late. 

Glenn eventually abandoned the water to change out of her cold bathing suit. Over her tacky skin she placed a light white dress purchased because the fabric reminded her of the frothiest part of a wave, the foam that can collect on the sand. Ever since she booked the cabin, a thought had formed in the back of her mind. Something about making a good impression on the sea. 

***

The moon’s golden crown began to rise over the water just before sunset. Kevin built a fire from the fallen branches in the yard. For hours they sat beside the firepit watching the elegant arc of the moon. Glenn held a glass of wine close to her lips and studied her free hand, which seemed to ripple in the wind-nurtured warmth. She was facing the water, staring too long at her own hand, when she saw something else. In the water. A flash of a tail, or maybe a fin. A shape both above the surface and partially submerged. She jumped up and ran to the water. Feet sinking in the high tide, she stumbled but did not stop. Whatever strange fish, she wanted to see it. 

“I saw something!” she called back to Kevin.

“Saw what?”

“A fin, I think.”

“Ba-dum.” 

MJ started to growl quietly in response. Kevin reached to calm her, before standing up to follow Glenn toward the water. He stood at the edge and gazed up at the moon.

“Did you know there’s a full moon tomorrow night? I wonder what kind of impact a full moon has on the tide during a hurricane.” When there was no response, he added, “So, what’d you see out there?” 

“Probably a great white shark,” Glenn grinned. “But perhaps a whale. Or a dolphin. Or something else.” 

“Perhaps.” 

He kissed her neck, rubbing his hands over her dress. Even in the dark, he could see her green eyes glowing like little aquariums. 

Sensing their closeness to each other, MJ wandered over to observe and then to startle. She barked, just once, as though to say, What are you fools doing? 

Kevin groaned. “Think she wants us to come back to the fire?” 

“Without a doubt.”

Hanging back, Glenn gave the water one last look, hoping to see what she’d seen before. A fin or a tail or something she didn’t even know. A sign of life. 

***

Glenn woke with a start. 

They’d passed out on separate couches last night with the Weather Channel on silent, the blue and white lights licking their faces as they slept. Stretching out her back, Glenn pointed her arms up toward the sky and stretched out in the style of a dive, holding that position for a while. But she could already tell the water was not her friend today. The wind shook the windows and whipped through the waves. 

Was it stupid, she wondered, naïve, even reckless, to try to withstand a hurricane? To put her faith in an unfamiliar old house? More than that, faith in the sea and in the wind. The hurricane was projected to hit the Outer Banks head-on, but meteorologists were calling it a swift storm, only forecast to last through the night. Gone by the following sunrise. 

In the bathroom Glenn was surprised by her own reflection in the mirror. The lines around her eyes had been sanded away and her lips were plump like they’d just remembered how to be pink.

She tiptoed across the crunchy carpet to the kitchen, slipping on her sandals at the front door. The plan forming in her mind was to brew coffee as quietly as possible, and then move outside to enjoy the storm alone. At that moment an especially strong gust punctuated her thoughts. She felt guilty for wanting to be alone, and crept over to kiss Kevin and their openly snoring dog. It isn’t wrong that you want to be alone, she consoled herself, it doesn’t mean you don’t love them.  

***

Kevin woke with a start. 

“What’s wrong?” he asked, jolting upright. The living room smelled of coffee, the dog was panting at the window, and Glenn’s blanket was deserted on the couch. Kevin assumed that she must be outside. At first this didn’t concern him, but then he heard the wind and thought of her out there swimming alone. 

He was relieved to see her standing at the end of the dock. There was a coffee mug in her hands as she stood facing the wind. 

Kevin let MJ out the back door and followed in his bare feet, sidestepping a tiny frog. Dragonflies were swarming the beach again, even as they fought against the wind. Kevin was surprised at the muted light that made the time of day indistinguishable. Thick clouds extended forever and were reflected in the waves. He couldn’t find the sun. 

Then he saw Glenn turn in his direction. She waved enthusiastically, placed her coffee on the dock, and stretched her arms out to dive into the water. 

“Wait!” he shouted just as she jumped. Her pointed hands collided first, followed by her face and upper body. The next second, she was gone. He couldn’t believe that she wanted to swim in this kind of water. Even under normal circumstances, Kevin didn’t like to go out past the point where his feet could touch the bottom. Swimming in deep water always gave him the sensation of being out of bounds.

To his relief, Glenn swam to shore right away. The shorts and T-shirt she slept in were completely soaked, clinging to her body like a devotee. It was enough to make him forget his concern entirely, or at least enough not to address it at that moment.

“It’s amazing out there.”

Kevin reached out to say good morning, but she shivered away.

“It’s freezing. I’m going to grab a towel.” 

Watching her run through the dragonflies, Kevin was only peripherally aware that he would one day leave her or at the very least stop loving her. He walked to the end of the dock to stand where she had stood, facing the wind, before kneeling to collect the coffee mug she abandoned. 

***

 The sky grew darker by the hour, and by noon there was no ignoring the rhythmic trembling coming from the house’s many, many windows. 

Glenn wanted to write but couldn’t stand to be inside or constrained in any way. The screened-in porch with its picnic table suited those needs. Just her, the water, and the page. Accumulating her thoughts, she extended the stretch before the dive. Glenn hadn’t written anything in over six months, so it was fair to be afraid. But I’m not afraid, she wrote in her notebook. There’s nothing to be afraid of when no one reads your work. That relieved a little tension. When at last she started to write, Glenn imagined her sentences soaring through the gray waves in the sky before landing softly on the page. 

By sunset there was no denying the storm. The Weather Channel was on silent again. In the kitchen Kevin chopped the ingredients for a salad, and Glenn admired his grace and assurance even in the subtlest movements. As the salad dressing passed wordlessly between them, she debated asking about Kevin’s day of writing before deciding against it—talking about his work would only lead to talking about her own. Instead they kept the drinks flowing, a coping mechanism that numbed her anxieties and increased Kevin’s. After dinner, he paced the room for a while, glancing out the window at every bolt of lightning, cracking his neck in time to the thunder. 

“MJ wants to cuddle with you on the couch,” Glenn said, trying to coax him into submission. She lit a few candles, covered both Kevin and MJ with a blanket, and soon enough, she had to snatch the glass out of his hand before he dropped it in his sleep. 

Downing the remains, she was relieved to be the only one awake with the storm. She pictured the way the water must be moving in a tangled, overlapping dance. If every wave was an arm collapsing into another arm or a leg crashing over a shoulder, then the ocean must contain an endless number of shifting bodies, dark bubbles born and bursting by the second. To play a part in the storm dance was Glenn’s strange desire at that moment. With a quick look back at her sleeping companions, she rose to accept her invitation. 

***

“What’s wrong?” Kevin asked. There was a whining. It was his dog. He needed to ask the dog what was wrong. But in his dream there was nothing other than the storm radar with a massive galaxy spinning across the world. There was no place for MJ in such a dream, so when he spoke, he was ripped away from the technicolor spiral only to return to the television’s gray static. 

Something told him Glenn was gone. The dog’s face in his lap, her desperate cry, the sound of the wind and only the wind, all of it felt familiar. He couldn’t see anything, but he knew Glenn wasn’t in the room. Kevin hurled himself from the couch and rushed to the windows. For the first time all night he felt the wind’s full impact on the cabin. He imagined the house flying off its stilts, carried into the air à la The Wizard of Oz, and leaving Glenn to the sea. 

Kevin raised his hands to his brow before leaning fully against the glass. His view was of dark, surging waves, the shivering dock, and Glenn kneeling in the shallows. Illuminated by the flickering porch light, she was just barely visible. He was noticing the glint of her hair blowing in the rain when he saw something else. In the water. A strong arm around her neck, pulling down. 

“She’s talking to someone,” he said to MJ, who barked in response. 

At the sound, Glenn’s head whipped around to look back at the house. The strong arm was gone. Kevin jumped back from the window, his whole body rippling in alarm. 

He watched her rise from the water and walk toward the house with her head high. When she came back inside, the wind slammed the door behind her. 

“What the fuck?” Kevin said. 

The dog had similar questions, but quickly settled down under the table like she knew what was about to happen. 

Glenn moved toward him. She planted her cold lips on his neck and her even colder hands on his beltline. Kevin shuddered in response. A second ago he wanted to fight with her, challenge her, accuse her of talking with a stranger in the waves—subjects that made no sense now that she was suctioning her body against his own, tugging at the jean shorts that gripped her thighs like a second skin. He watched her step out of her underwear as though in triumph. When she pushed his back against the window and hooked him into place with one leg, Kevin suddenly found it all too easy to embrace the idea that none of this was even happening.

***

The storm was over by dawn, leaving plentiful sunshine and riptides in its wake. The flat expanse of the sound looked like an endless bed with innumerable sheets being pulled in all directions. At the head of that bed was Glenn, sitting cross-legged at the end of the dock with her back to the house yet again. 

Kevin’s first inkling that something was off: an unsettling absence of coffee. Glenn never did anything in the morning without coffee. MJ was unsettled too; he woke to her curled near his feet at the foot of the bed instead of looking out the window. She seemed scared, but Kevin dismissed it as lingering stress from the storm. He let her out with him as he walked from the porch down to the water. 

Kevin would’ve had to wade into knee-high depths to even reach the partially submerged dock. Instead he called out to Glenn from the shore. “Who were you talking to last night?” 

Glenn’s head shook as if startled from a daze. She didn’t stand to walk toward him but shifted to reveal her open notebook, the pages flapping wildly in the wind.

“Are you writing?” he asked. 

“I was writing. Who was I talking to when?”  

“Last night,” he said, a little quieter. Suddenly he felt guilty for interrupting. “When you came out here in the storm like a crazy person.” 

“Oh, don’t be so dramatic,” Glenn said, before switching her attention to write something down. Then she closed her notebook and stood up, stretching. “I wasn’t talking to anyone. Why did you lie about the driver on the bridge?”  

It took him a long time to make sense of her question. He looked from side to side to see whether there was anyone around to witness this confounding accusation—just MJ shitting in the tall grass. Then he did see someone in the distance. A man was standing on the pristine lawn of the neighboring house. Kevin couldn’t make out his face, but this man was clearly looking in their direction. Then the neighbor whistled, and a dog, another golden retriever, came galloping out of the house. 

When Kevin turned back to the dock, Glenn was already writing again. 

Envious of her sudden vigor, Kevin’s only response was to follow her lead. But he never gained the momentum he wanted from the morning. For him, writing meant to detach from the earth. He didn’t like to have one foot on the ground and one in the sky. His best pages were always written in ecstatic states of blackout, leaving no one but himself to take the credit. But Glenn’s flirtations with disaster had distracted him, kept his eyes on the dock instead of the page. 

Now, as Glenn sat across from him at the picnic table for lunch, her face, shoulders, and arms looked blushed, not burnt, and her hair was a golden tangle. She was unshowered and salty and it suited her. Meanwhile his own fingernails were staining a deeper orange by the day thanks to the iron-rich well water. 

As they ate the sandwiches Kevin had made, he spoke about his struggle to get his ideas organized. But he noticed that when he spoke, she didn’t acknowledge him. Instead she chewed her food steadily, reached down to pet MJ once in a while, but other than that, kept her eyes on the sound. 

The next time Kevin looked up from his work, the pink sky shocked him. He stretched, yawning like a satisfied seal. Then he looked for Glenn in her usual spot, but all he saw was her abandoned notebook resting on top of the clothes she’d been wearing earlier. 

He stood up from the picnic table and called out her name. Already too many times this week he’d had this exact same experience, ripped from a dreamworld by her absence. 

“Where is she, MJ?” 

As he scanned the water, his mind was consumed by different combinations of Glenn drowning or being eaten by sharks. In the distance Kevin noticed the neighbor on the lawn with his dog again. Following the neighbor’s eyeline, he saw a figure swimming in the distance. The stranger wasn’t just admiring the scenery. He was watching Glenn swim.

When Glenn came back to shore, MJ didn’t charge down the beach to greet her. Kevin also kept his place. 

“Sorry for swimming where you couldn’t see me,” Glenn said, patting him on the cheek with a bloated hand and ignoring MJ altogether. 

MJ looked up at Kevin, noticeably nonplussed by the snub. He thought he should offer her a consolation prize, so he reached into the shallows, looking for a rock or a seashell to throw into the waves. Instead he alighted on a soft object covered in slippery kelp. Brushing away the strands, he saw that the slimy sensation came from the object itself—a palm-sized silver scale. With disgust he tossed the fish debris back into the water. Even MJ didn’t deign to follow. 

Kevin’s paranoia lingered through dinner. He didn’t plan to say anything about the nude swimming; instead he focused on the fact that Glenn hadn’t yet asked to drive across the harbor to the beach. When she first started planning this trip, all she talked about was the beach. How they needed to see the sunrise over the water and look for the wild horses. 

“We’re over the halfway point of our trip,” Kevin reminded her. “Should we set an alarm early tomorrow and watch the sunrise?” 

Glenn flinched before returning to her burger. “Sure,” she said between bites. “But let’s not be gone long. I have more work to get done.” 

“Of course. So do I.” 

In bed he recited their nightly mantra, “Sleep the sleep of a thousand sleeps.” The phrase came from their first summer as a couple, when blue whales patterned Glenn’s bedsheets. He waited for the usual response, but it never came. 

Rolling over on her side, she responded automatically. No thousand sleeps. No whales. Only, “Good night.” 

Kevin closed his eyes and wondered where he’d lost her. 

***

An hour before sunrise Kevin rose from the empty bed. Through the balcony doors he saw Glenn sleeping on the dock, surrounded by seagulls. He sighed and shook his head at the yawning dog. He told himself he’d make the best of their day, try to get back on the same page, the same page they’d always been on together. Kevin went through the motions of preparing for the beach. In the dark he carried coffee to her, disturbing the gulls.

“Good morning,” he said loudly enough to wake her. With his foot he pushed a fish carcass into the water.

The drive from the cabin to the beach was quiet apart from MJ’s head out the window, snarfing down wind. But it wasn’t the quiet that bothered Kevin. It was something even more intangible than silence. 

The sun rose. Glenn lay down on sand that was as cool and soft as a sheet while Kevin threw the ball for MJ. But the only time she seemed to truly enjoy herself was when she spotted a group of dolphins breaching on the horizon. And then once more, an hour or so later, when Kevin thought to ask her about what she’d been writing out on the dock. Usually Glenn was reserved when it came to talking about her work, but this time she was all too eager to describe her new project, a story she said was inspired by the ocean itself. 

“In my story, the sea is kind of a mentor. A spiritual guide.” 

Kevin was a little fuzzy on the actual premise, but that didn’t matter because at least she was excited about something again. The key, he thought, was to meet her enthusiasm halfway. 

“I’m also writing about the sea,” he told her, “only mine is a man-versus-self story masquerading as a man-versus-nature story . . .” 

But he saw her become instantly bored, staring off into the distance like she was willing the dolphins to resurface. It wasn’t too long after that she requested they return to the cabin.

By the time the sun went down, Kevin had been pacing back and forth in the screened-in porch for hours. Glenn was still writing on the dock, but he refused to disturb her, even though he wondered how she could even see well enough to write under the meager glow of the overcast moon. 

An unfamiliar bark halted Kevin in his pacing. MJ jumped to attention too, sniffing the air. The bark came again, more demanding. Leaving MJ on the porch, he crept down the stairs to investigate. He’d forgotten to turn on the porch light, so when he first reached the grass, he couldn’t see anything. He tried whistling. Soon enough a dog wandered out of the tall grass by the dock. 

“Hey, buddy. Where’d you come from?” 

As the dog moved closer, Kevin recognized the familiar coat and assumed it was the neighbor’s. Then the dog started to meander down the driveway toward the gravel road. Part of him was tempted to leave the dog to its own devices, but he’d never been one to abandon a task halfway. 

The dog seemed relieved to transition from the gravel to the long blacktop driveway, letting out a sigh and picking up the pace. From below, the mansion seemed smaller than it appeared at a distance. When Kevin stepped between the colonial pillars to ring the doorbell, he couldn’t help but think of a shark’s mouth. Of long columns of teeth biting down. 

He rang the doorbell once and then a second time with an urgency akin to the dog’s follow-up bark. This time, though, the dog was patient, sitting regally at Kevin’s feet. For some reason Kevin was holding his breath.

At last, trudging footsteps became audible. 

“Who’s there?” 

“I’m sorry to bother you, but I think your dog wandered over to our yard.” 

When the door opened and revealed a shirtless man, the dog immediately jumped to its feet. 

“Get inside, Boomer, you asshole,” the man roared, and then leaned against the door, assessing Kevin. “Sorry about that. We don’t often have folks renting that property, so Boomer thinks the place is his own. Probably smelled your cute dog and wanted to check her out. You enjoying your time in our graveyard?” 

Kevin frowned. “Excuse me?” Then he remembered Glenn telling him about the area’s morbid nickname, a reference to the uncanny number of shipwrecks. “That’s right. The Graveyard of the Atlantic.” 

The neighbor smiled. 

“Apart from the storm, it’s been great,” Kevin said, thinking of Glenn on the dock. “My partner and I are both writers, so we’ve been trying to get some work done.”

“Writers.” The man nodded as though acknowledging a mutually understood euphemism. “Right.” 

Kevin might’ve been imagining it, but it looked like this man was flexing his muscles, which were fully on display under the porch light. 

“Anyway. I’ll let you get back to it. Glad to get Boomer home safe.” 

But the stranger kept on smiling as though the conversation wasn’t over. Then, when Kevin was already halfway down the driveway, he heard the man shout.

“What’s that?” Kevin called back.

“I saw your wife the other day,” the man yelled, his voice echoing under the portico. “Strong swimmer.”

Disoriented, Kevin started to respond, “She’s not my—” He cut himself off. The entire interaction evoked the most vivid sense of déjà vu. But even if he’d already dreamed this conversation, he had no intention of sticking around to remember how it ended. 

An idea hooked Kevin when he was back at the rental and a few drinks into the early hours of the morning. Not a new idea for his story, but another more invasive idea, irresistible as an itch in the back of his throat. What if Glenn had already met the neighbor? What if he came over and introduced himself one of the times that Glenn was out there alone? What if she swam out there, naked and glowing, for him? What if that was the real reason why she’d been spending so much time—so many nights and early mornings and hurricanes—outside? Kevin became fixated on this idea until it became the only idea. 

***

He couldn’t remember passing out, but when he woke up the next morning, the first thing Kevin noticed was the scent of coffee. This gave him hope—maybe Glenn was finally coming back to earth now that their vacation was almost over. In the late-morning light he wasn’t as upset about the neighbor, just confused. The muscular yachtsman didn’t seem her type. But he didn’t blame Glenn for wanting something different after all this time. Pouring himself coffee, anticipating the jolt, he felt at peace with the situation. But when he took the first sip, that peace was ruptured. His palate reacted instinctually, and he spat out the liquid into the air. Kevin flailed, turned to the sink, and tipped his mouth under the faucet. Tan as the well water was, at least it wasn’t salt. 

Collecting himself and wiping his hand across his mouth, Kevin surveyed the half-empty coffeepot. He lifted the canister to his nose and smelled it immediately: seawater mixed with coffee grounds. 

Rushing to the window, he saw Glenn in her usual spot, writing away, only pausing to tilt a white mug to her lips. He gagged a little and ran outside with his arms flailing. For the first time in all the years he’d known her, he could find no rationale for her behavior; this was what frightened him most. He’d left MJ inside and could hear her scratching at the door, but there wasn’t time to turn back. By the height of the sun it was almost noon. Glenn could’ve been drinking that coffee for hours already. 

“Glenn!”  Kevin’s feet were raw from days of hot sand and spiky grass, and he winced a little on the dock. “Throw out your coffee right now!” 

But she was rushing with her handwriting, hunched as close to the page as possible. Kevin didn’t understand how she could see at all with the sun fully exposed. Her face looked redder than the rest of her body, and he wondered if the paper’s bright reflection was damaging her skin. He knelt in front of her and tossed the contents of the mug into the sound. 

“Hey!” She perked up. “What’d you do that for?” 

“That coffee was brewed with salt water. Seawater. What were you thinking?” 

She shook her head, wrote something down, and then looked up. “I don’t know what you’re talking about.” 

“Are you fucking with me? I’d actually really love it if you were fucking with me.” 

“Kevin, please. Can’t you see I’m in the zone here? Do I ever interrupt you when you’re in the zone?” 

“No, you don’t, but when I’m in the zone, I don’t make coffee with toxic water.” 

“You don’t make coffee, period.” 

Not knowing what else to do, Kevin threw up his hands and walked back to the house, ignoring the pain in his feet. He retrieved a glass of fresh water and brought it back to her. 

“Please drink this.” He was relieved when she did so. “Hey, what would you say to leaving the cabin a night early? I think MJ’s ready to go home.” 

Invoking the dog was a manipulative tactic, but it was one he hoped would work. 

“MJ’s fine,” Glenn dismissed with a harsher voice than he’d ever heard her use. “It’s you who wants to leave. I already know you didn’t want to come in the first place, and I know you wished we’d turned around when we heard about the hurricane. Look, I’m so close to finishing this thing and what I need right now is for you to just take care of your own life and let me take care of mine, okay? We’re leaving tomorrow. Deal with it.” 

Kevin’s eyes started to tear, but Glenn didn’t notice. The house down the shore was perfectly placed as her backdrop. Kevin had the sense once more that it appeared larger and more imposing from a distance, the inverse of the safety warning printed on the side-view mirror: OBJECTS IN THE MIRROR ARE FATHER THAN THEY APPEAR. 

He understood that if he didn’t prepare for departure, no one would, so he spent the day polishing off the LandShark and completing the domestic tasks usually handled by Glenn. His whole being was focused on getting them out of this house, away from the ocean, and back to their home in the mountains. From the moment they left, it seemed their relationship had been put in danger. It made him sad to pack up the board games and the movies that Glenn had brought, storing them away like leftovers of an untouched meal. Here was proof that at some point she’d wanted to spend time together, that she hadn’t intended to be so absent and caught up in her own world. Vacuuming as much sand as he could from the old carpet, he tried to retrace their steps, combing his memory for clues. The answer was obvious; he didn’t need to move the magnifying glass far to find it. The lightning storm and the car stopped over the river were what started it all. Then the discrepancy between what he and the other driver had seen in the car. Was it possible that what they witnessed was a reflection of their own fears? Their futures? He wished he could talk to Glenn about his theory. Probably she already knew the truth. 

***

Glenn came up for air and hoisted herself from the water to the dock in one fluid flight. The dock was high above the water, but she’d taught herself to ride the wave, harness its elevation, and position her arms and legs in such a way as to hook onto the wooden underbelly like an opportunistic barnacle. From there she could climb ashore without even touching the shore. If she had splinters, she couldn’t feel them.

She had to get down her next line.

The story had taken on its own gravity, its own tidal current that Glenn had no interest in resisting. This week her thoughts were more focused than ever before. Each sentence seemed to curl out from her temples before alighting effortlessly on the page. She was thriving on the rhythmic flapping of the waves against the dock, an organic metronome keeping her in time. Her hands were blistered, pruned, nearly numb, and her handwriting grew more cryptic by the minute. But the story was there in front of her, waiting to end. Endings had never been her strength; she had a feeling this story would change all that and more. The ending would come to her just as the rest of the story had come to her, like a wish for something she already held.

When she heard the now-familiar sound of the waves parting below her, smooth as a sliding screen door, she lay down to brush her fingertips across the shifting reflection. Glenn knew if she just looked a little longer, a little deeper into the mirror, the ending would swim forth to swallow her whole. 

***

The sky was split in half that night. Beyond the banks, a storm was brewing. Overhead, the unveiled face of the moon carried on with her gentle recoil. 

Kevin walked outside with MJ, stumbling slightly, to admire the polarity of stars and storm. Turning his gaze toward the dock, he was not surprised by what he saw there. What surprised him was the position they were in, with Glenn on the dock and the stranger in the water. They couldn’t very well accomplish what they wanted to accomplish from that angle, Kevin thought. Under the moonlight he could see it all: Glenn’s upper body leaning off the pier, her arms clinging to the body below, the same strong arms holding her neck. 

Blinking his eyes and adjusting his glasses, he thought he saw something else. Something in the water. Only this time it wasn’t a fin, it was—though it couldn’t be—horns. Something with the curved horns of a goat was talking to Glenn, whispering in her ear. Kevin fastened his gaze, desperate to see his mistake. Directly behind the horned stranger, Kevin watched as a shape ascended from the water. Corkscrewing above the surface, winding high in the air to embrace Glenn with its dripping iridescence, was a forked tail. 

At that moment MJ registered his terror and responded in kind, barking at a painfully high pitch. He gasped, clamped his hands over his ears, and knelt to calm the dog. But it was too late. Both Glenn and the creature that held her turned in the direction of the house. Kevin forced himself to look away from Glenn and into the face of the creature in the water. Above its two eyes a third, larger eye was blinking in the center of its forehead. Then all three eyes focused on Kevin. Even at a distance, he could see the boundless whirlpools within.

Kevin grabbed MJ by the collar and dragged her inside. Locking the doors, pulling down the blinds, gasping for breath, he hoped and did not hope that Glenn would try to come back in the house. Truly he hoped that she did come back, but that when she did, she’d be alone. 

***

In the morning Kevin woke up with only an hour until they were meant to leave the rental. Only an hour until they were meant to return to their lives. After what he saw last night, he didn’t think it possible. He’d stayed awake as long as he could, but Glenn never came back inside. For a time he was able to convince himself that what he saw was in his imagination—he’d been writing strange stories lately, and having even stranger dreams—but then why hadn’t she returned? Had she really been massacred by a sea monster, something part fish, part goat, part person? There was also the story she mentioned at the beach about the spiritual guide. That thought made him vomit into the toilet, the contents tinted orange from the well water.

He locked MJ in the house before facing his doom. Far off in the distance a waterspout was spinning in place, connecting the sound to a disk of dark clouds in the sky. For a moment Kevin marveled at the funnel, so white it could almost be mistaken for a beam of light, and startlingly slender, like a single tentacle of a celestial squid. 

Not knowing what else he would see in the water, Kevin assumed the worst. Instead he saw Glenn swimming, all of her perfectly intact, floating on her back near the edge of the water. Her notebook was washed ashore, soaked by the tide and half-buried in wet sand.

Cautiously but without fear, Kevin waded out to her. White froth clung to the exposed parts of her body, and her hair haloed in the water. A hint of sun shower was twinkling in the breeze.

Glenn gazed up at him, looking entirely at peace. 

“I finished it. I finished the story.” 

Kevin knew this was his moment. Suddenly the choice felt simple, a clear path she’d laid out before him. He watched the path lengthen, then deviate, branching out in all directions. Where he stood led in one direction, steady and ahead. Where Glenn stood led in another, inward and away. 

“That’s wonderful. I’m so happy for you.” 

The radiance of her smile warmed him to the core. Glenn reached out from the water for his hand. For a moment he held it, kissed it, and looked her once more in the eyes. 

“I hope you sleep the sleep of a thousand sleeps.” 

 “A thousand sleeps with the whales.” 

Kevin smiled as he watched her slip under the warm blanket of the shallows. For the first time he felt at ease with the flutter of movement by his submerged legs. It was a comfort to know that among the many monsters, she too was out there swimming. 

He packed up all their things, every last item they brought on their vacation. When the time came to lead MJ to the car, she didn’t even look back at the water. Perhaps the transition from one state of being into the next was something that a dog could innately understand. With last-minute hesitation Kevin thought to leave the door open, the key in the lock. There was no particular reason why he did this; it just felt right. 

On his way out of town, he decided to stop at the one and only grocery store. Exhausted and mildly hungover, coffee was required. At the checkout counter the attendant asked about their trip. Had he and his wife gotten a lot of writing done?

“Sure did. My writing partner especially.” 

He carried the coffee back to the car, comforted the dog in the back seat, and turned on the radio. Kevin was surprised by how free he felt, how inspired by the road ahead. He wasn’t sure what he thought about man-versus-nature anymore, but the prospect of following his own thoughts like bright trail markers made the long journey alone seem like a rewarding climb. 

 


Taylor Sykes’s writing has appeared or is forthcoming in The Midwest Review, LIT Magazine, So to Speak, The Masters Review, NPR’s All Things Considered, and elsewhere. She is the recipient of the James Hurst Prize for Fiction and a 35 in 35 Fellowship from the Vermont Studio Center. Originally from northwest Indiana, she has an MFA in fiction from North Carolina State University and teaches creative writing at the University of North Carolina Asheville.