Hope Cracking through the Dirt: on Michael Waters’s ‘Pagan Sky’

by Andreevich Tew

Michael Waters’s new book Pagan Sky spans twenty-five years of travel, relationships, and contemplation. Combining work from his previous books—Darling Vulgarity, Gospel Night, Celestial Joyride, The Dean of Discipline, Caw, and Sinnerman—alongside uncollected poems from journals and new, never-before-seen work, this book provides a great bird’s-eye view of Waters’s work while at the same time zooming into the minutiae and specificity of his worlds. For someone new to Waters, as I am, this book serves as a ledger for where his poems have been, and proof that Waters is still traveling to new and stranger places as a poet.

This book’s name features in the title poem in the “New Poems” section, and still earlier in “Table on the Edge of the World.” In the latter poem, Waters’s speaker declares:

              Those days of the ’80s have receded

              Like wheel ruts below silted seabed,

              Stone roads leading nowhere

              Once the volcano blackened pagan skies.

              Wherever we live, some part of us dies.

In this poem I see a playing with time and memory, a signature I’ve found in most of Waters’s poems, as the days we remember are overcome by the ocean, and roads that used to lead to houses or markets, now after natural disaster, lead nowhere. Our memory alters and alienates us from our past selves and the places we have been previously; however, Waters still makes the statement “Wherever we live, some part of us dies.” This passage sums up what I see Waters doing throughout this entire book, showing the reader all the places his speakers have died. This might sound like a morbid statement, but I believe this speaker takes hope in it, knowing that even if his memory might be separated, there is still a part of himself that is left there. Another thing I find interesting about this passage is its use of rhyme, which pops up occasionally throughout the collection when something feels important. The rhyme of “skies” and “dies” ties the two of them together, linking the real-life catastrophe with the metaphorical death as the speaker left the place in his youth.

Waters’s writing here demonstrates the imaginative power poetry allows, connecting the real world to the imagined world. His poem “Ashkenazi Birthmark” constantly shifts from the grounded and touchable to the ethereal and ponderable, even at the very beginning:

              Maybe the parapsychologists are right

              To claim that birthmarks

              Intimate wounds sustained in prior lives,

In the first line, I am caught off guard by this very scientific word and put into a very grounded place; however, by the end of the stanza I am floating above these specifics and asked to imagine previous lives and, with the line break, examine what an “intimate wound” would look like. As the poem continues, it returns to the grounded, an ancestral connection to a great-uncle who was executed in 1942 in Vinnytsia, Ukraine, which at the time was under Nazi occupation. Immediately after this digging into history, the poem asks me to ponder my own belief in souls as the speaker goes on to grieve the rest of his family and to admit he will never know for certain what this great-uncle’s name was.

There is great imaginative power in the ghost of the great-uncle. While this is not as strict a locational setting as “Table on the Edge of the World,” we still see that same movement of something left behind. The part of this great-uncle that died does not sit still and fade into oblivion, but instead it plants itself onto the speaker’s body.

Most of these parts of Waters’s speakers do not just stay planted in the places they are left, but instead they grow into new things. “Report from October” hits this point the most directly. In the poem the direct setting is a street with children trick-or-treating; however, these kids are not described as laughing or running around, but instead “staggering.” The friendly neighborhood street becomes a “gauntlet of goblins.” The epigraph of the poem gives the most clarity into why this hometown street has become monstrous: “Ocean, NJ / Kyiv / Gaza.” There is some part of the speaker in all of these places, to the point where they have begun to blur together, and they can’t help but overlap tragedy and holiday. The poem ends with “Horror near, horror far,” which points directly to this point: The parts of the speaker that have died still have the ability to haunt.

Another less concrete and more familial example of this haunting comes from “Pedestrian Mall,” in which we see the speaker and his wife strolling “near dusk / Past the shuttered Sunglass Hut,” encountering someone he knew, his “humdrum colleague,” arguing with the colleague’s partner. There is something so embarrassing about the way the speaker sees himself abandoning his wife to confront this other couple that, by the time he returns to hold her hand again, he states directly, “I was no longer her faithful husband.” Even in the distance of a few short feet and a couple of minutes, there is some irretrievable part of the speaker left behind in that mall kiosk, something lost in the darkness of the store, so that when he, as the poem describes, “emerges” from that darkness, a part of him has died. It is not only the worldwide and colossal that causes these fragmentations, but also the small moments in the dark that linger on.

What fascinates me about this collection is the way Waters goes about healing these fragments of speakers left behind in these poems, haunted by familial trauma and violence. To me, his poem ‘Black Sea Spa’ points most clearly to his instructions for healing. In the poem, the speaker and an unidentified “you” are in the Black Sea spa, surrounded by older men in the mud baths. The poem mainly features the speaker and “you” looking outside the window; however, the poem ends by gesturing back to these old men:

              As though the hammer still fell on this last

              Generation to have suffered world war,

              Who heal themselves by interring themselves

              In curative earth before the last death.

The hammer in these lines sticks out to me as being a curious symbol, perhaps representing an oppressive force meant to destroy or instead a blacksmith’s hammer meant to mold for use. Either way, we get this Hemingwayesque view of the old men representing the old guard, returning to the earth via these mud baths for healing. To me, this ‘last death’ points back to the other deaths these men have left in the places they lived before, a direct reference to “Table on the Edge of the World.” This again blends the real, the mud baths and spa, with this abstract idea of burial and the smaller deaths we leave behind. Through this lens, Waters’s travel is not just for historical appreciation or leisure, but becomes a process of interring, burying himself back into the earth for healing. The places these speakers live are seeded with imagination and self, and as the book continues, we see them begin to bloom.

Lastly, this review would be incomplete without looking at the title poem of this collection, “Pagan Sky,” especially because it draws all of these ideas together. The poem has an epigraph, “Las Terrenas / Dominican Republic / 2020.” I did some background research and learned that Las Terrenas was known during the pandemic for having lots of people suddenly move there as digital nomads, people who still had jobs elsewhere but, because that work had moved online, decided to live somewhere more beautiful. All of this information informs the speaker’s background in that first line, “Our pandemic proved a pleasure.” Whereas “Table on the Edge of the World” had no mention of gods, this poem names “the hands-off gods,” “those avuncular gods,” “the less affectionate gods,” and finally, “the hooting gods.” This play between all these namings of the same or different gods and the pagan sky of the title asks the reader to examine what the bloom of this fragment leaves them, which makes me think of these gods being the parts of the people already detaching from themselves to transform. However, this poem spends the most time exploring the journeys of this pluralized speaker as they walk the beaches, which become the Garden of Eden. By the end of the poem, we see the ‘we’ become Adam and Eve, healed of whatever hardships they might have experienced before:

              Where the sun still rose each day

                            Until we shone like the first

                                          Two people on the planet, not yet

 

              Guilt-ridden, unashamed

                            To be naked & alive

                                          Below all the hooting gods.

As the speakers travel back to a place where they can appreciate the earth and spend time in the sand together, they are able to feel unashamed of themselves, which we can infer has not previously been the case. The “hooting gods” at the end feel completely different from the “hands-off gods” at the beginning; the hooting gods feel animalistic, celebratory, and proud of the speakers for undergoing this healing.

Pagan Sky delights in all the different places that Waters’s speakers travel and the healing the process provides them. I personally admire the specificity in language, the care afforded to all of these characters, and the courage to let things grow outside their original contexts. While the world around Waters’s speakers is filled with destruction, violence, and hauntings, there is still hope cracking through the dirt, learning to unfurl its leaves.


ANDREEVICH TEW is an MFA candidate in poetry at UNC Greensboro, where works as the MFA Program Assistant. He also serves at the North Carolina Poetry Society as VP of Programming. He is honored to host the monthly UNCG undergraduate open mic as well as NCPS's monthly zoom open mic, and he is incredibly grateful for his opportunity to serve his NC poets' community.