A Lie Worth Believing

by William Hawkins

Miss Bernie said an angel knocked on her bedroom window the night she turned sixteen. The angel had come to tell her she’d have four children—she did—that she’d live to grow old and fat—she did—and that, on the day she died, the angel would return and piggyback her to heaven. We called her a liar; she remained supremely unbothered. What were three bratty children to an angel’s promise? Later, after our parents came home from work and relieved Miss Bernie, we asked Mama—Amanda asked Mama—if what Miss Bernie said was true. Mama said, Ask your father. Dad said, Bernie is the only honest woman God put on earth. Then he told us to leave the poor old woman alone.

Miss Bernie wasn’t old. She was ancient. She’d watched over Dad when he was a kid, as she now watched over us. She had great-grandchildren in high school. Amanda said there’d be great-greats soon. She’d heard Dad say there were more Clarks than rabbits before Mama shushed him. The long and short of it was, Miss Bernie had been around as long as there had been an around to be. So naturally we didn’t believe Amanda when she came out in the backyard and told us Miss Bernie was dead on the couch. 

“She’s not,” Everett said. Everett was always the first to deny Amanda. “You’re a liar.”

“I am not.” She was. My sister Amanda was the great liar of our childhood. She fibbed as she breathed. She was the oldest child, Dad’s favorite. I was the baby, Mama’s favorite, her difficult birth, the sensitive soul. Everett was nobody’s favorite.

“You’re a fat liar, Amanda Jean,” he said.

“Come see,” Amanda said. “Come see if I’m lying.”

Everett went. I stayed behind with the army men. Everett and I had divided the whole bag between us. They were fighting a civil war in the soft dirt near the toolshed. I killed every last one of Everett’s men. I was busy burying them when I felt my brother’s and sister’s shadows come over me.

“Okay, JW. It’s your turn.”

“I won’t.”

“She’s really dead, JW,” Everett said. “I promise.”

“It’s your turn,” my sister said again.

“Eat dirt.” 

“It’s time, JW,” Amanda said.

“You have to,” Everett said.

If I had stayed in the dirt, they would have piled on me, and Amanda would have twisted my arm until I cried uncle through the taste of my hot tears. I hated them. I wanted to be giant when I grew up and grind them into the sidewalk with one shoe.

I got up, said, “I’m not scared,” and pushed past them. Everett said, “She’s really dead, JW.” Amanda shushed him. I figured then, with her shushing, it was all another big lie. I marched to the porch, back straight as any plastic soldier. They’d left the sliding door open. They were letting the air out. “You’re letting all the air out!” I shouted back at them. They hadn’t gone far from the toolshed; they were waiting for me to chicken out. I went inside.

The TV was still on Miss Bernie’s stories. Two blond women argued like sparrows over a dining table. Miss Bernie was on the couch. Her eyes were half-open. She was dead. I knew by  the way the couch looked alive under her. I looked at her for the longest time. Our Miss Bernie, in her daffodil muumuu, her thick legs open, her skin gone gray. She’d already started back to ashes. Ashes and ashes, dust and dust, and I couldn’t move. Looking took all my strength.

“Touch her.” This was Amanda, standing in the open doorway, Everett peeping over her shoulder. “Go on and touch her and see.”

“She’s dead,” I said.

“Touch her.”

My evil sister. It was late spring. She’d started to freckle. They ran across her nose, bridging her cheeks. My sister never liked Miss Bernie. She preferred Miss Dolores, who cleaned on Tuesdays and did the ironing on Thursdays. Miss Dolores would smile at whatever Amanda said. Miss Bernie always called her a liar.

“No way.”

“Open her mouth,” my sister said.

“No.”

“Don’t you know anything?” my sister asked. “You have to open her mouth so her soul can get out. She’s stuck in there until you do. The angel can’t get her to heaven till you do.”

“That’s not true.”

“It is so.” My brilliant sister. “You have to help her, JW. The angel’s up there waiting.”

“We need to call Mama,” Everett said. There was a crack in his voice; his lower lip jutted. “Let’s call Mama.”

“Go on, JW.”

“You,” I said.

“I’m not scared,” Amanda said. The great liar. “Watch.”

She walked right up to Miss Bernie. She might’ve hesitated, sure, but she stepped right up to Miss Bernie, right between her legs—Miss Bernie’s limp, splayed legs. Miss Bernie’s mouth was already a little open. And Amanda reached up, on tippy-toe, but lost her balance—never a ballerina, our sister Amanda—and fell. Right into Miss Bernie’s still bosom. Amanda screamed then, a high-pitched scream she pretended not to have, and thrashed about, tried to push away. But Miss Bernie was a sinkhole. My poor sister had to throw herself off, hitting the ground. I saw Miss Bernie’s jaw drop. And no soul rushed out. Amanda cried, Everett went running for the phone, and nothing came out of Miss Bernie, nothing but the nothing of an empty throat. I went back outside, to the soft dirt near the toolshed, which is where Dad found me, shaking over my plastic soldiers, and it took every soft lie he had in him to coax me back into the house. 

 


William Hawkins has been published in Granta, ZYZZYVA and TriQuarterly, among others. Originally from Louisiana, he currently lives in Los Angeles where he is at work on a novel. Read more of his writing at oncetherewas.substack.com.