10:00
Even before the service started, Brie was curled over, hands clasped. She closed her eyes. She began to pray that John would quit drinking, because she knew that was the only way they’d get their baby back. Even though John told her they got him taken away because she was crazy—even if he didn’t want to admit it—she knew the truth. In fact her case manager had told her so straight to her face. “If John doesn’t quit drinking,” he’d said, “you won’t be able to get James back.” “I had no idea he was drinking!” she cried. But she did know John was drinking—she did know. So why did she say she didn’t know? She’d become a liar. But it was John who made her act that way—ever since she met him. So she prayed hard about that, about John’s drinking, but mostly about her own lying, her head bent down between her knees because while she did like to pray aloud, she didn’t necessarily want the people around her to know exactly what she was saying. There was a lot of shame in those secrets.
Sometimes she even had a hard time remembering the little things. The shape of his pinky toe, what song she used to sing to him. It was just over six months since he’d been taken from her, and she’d only seen him three times since then. If only John would change, she thought, looking up at the clock, back down at the plum carpet between her blue flip-flops. The last time they were supposed to see their baby, when she’d found out he’d failed the urine test, she confronted John and said, “You know what, John? I’m beginning to think you don’t even want to get James back. I’m beginning to think you’re trying to fail.”
10:15
The little choir, all dressed in white, started to gather. The twin brothers wore white suits with satin ties; they were both blind, so one of their wives walked between them, her arms hooked with each one. The old lady who played the piano sat down and touched a couple of keys as if she were touching them for the first time, hesitant like a child with a new toy.
“Blessed morning,” people whispered as they arrived; Brie watched them slide into the pews around her. A few people from the “new members” group, which met twice a month—who’d heard her whole story last Sunday, who, she started to realize, knew everything about her now—said hello as they passed and sat down in the back. Brie had sat in the back at first too, but now she sat in the second row.
It didn’t matter to her church family that she was homeless, which she was honest about from day one. She’d been accepted. It was meant to be that they’d gotten into the shelter just a few blocks away—they’d been calling and calling and calling—the only shelter with a room for a couple in Denver. There was no way she was going to be separated from John. No way she was going to stay in a shelter without him, all those crazy people around her. She was glad she held out. And the foster people—Christians, like her—had even said that they would bring him by the church that morning so that she could see him on his birthday and introduce James to her church family. John wouldn’t get to see him. He wasn’t there because he did not believe in God, which—though she would never say it to his face—she believed was the reason he was under the power of alcohol.
Brie had grown up in a church like this, with women who’d put their cold, perfumed hands on your face and say, Smile. Where people were encouraged to praise God as they wanted to—sing, stomp, shout. There were moments when she felt at home. Still, Brie had been surprised to hear herself start to tell them her story—but they’d been going around the circle and as she realized their stories were not so different from her own, suddenly it was her turn—to hear herself tell them, these people she’d only known a couple of months, how she’d asked John to take the baby for a minute, an hour, just one hour, how she’d just needed a little help, but instead he went out drinking, and she was left with the baby all night, all by herself. “I just had to take a walk,” she told the other new members. Across from her and on both sides, around the table where they also had Bible study, they’d listened as Brie continued, keeping her eyes on the wrinkled, brown hand of one woman, smoothing out the red tablecloth, brushing the coffee cake crumbs from it into her palm beneath the table—which, for some reason, had been comforting to Brie. “I had to clear my mind because—” Way back in her throat, even before they got to her eyes, the tears had started—but the pastor said, “That’s just fine. Go on, dear.” She told them how she hadn’t been thinking right, how she hadn’t been gone more than ten minutes or so when she saw the police car heading toward their place. Instinctively she ran back. She hadn’t run like that since before she found out she was pregnant—she hadn’t known if it was safe for the baby growing inside of her, taking root—but she ran up the stairs, found the officers talking to her neighbor, the lady who’d called the cops on them, who hated her anyway, always banging on the door when John and her were just having a simple disagreement. “I’m sorry!” Brie had cried. “I just—” She was trying to tell the officers something about how she couldn’t take the screaming, and once John started up, of course, the baby did too—but that didn’t stop those cops from entering her home, and even though she ran ahead of them, trying to comfort James, who was still crying, they started looking around as if she weren’t there at all. They didn’t see that—how good she was at comforting him in that moment and singing that song he loved and pressing him to her breast until he bit down, no matter how much it hurt—what they cared about was how the bathroom ceiling, which they were looking at with mouths open, had caved in, filling up their tub with dirt and bits of wet wood and little rocks. “How do they shower?” she’d heard one of the cops say, though Brie didn’t share this part. What she said was, “There was only so much I could do with what I had.” The landlord never came to fix it, never returned her call, and he was the only one who’d rent to them since John was a felon because of that dumb, piece-of-junk car that broke down only a week after he stole it from the shop where he worked for, what, two whole months?—Yes, the place could’ve been cleaner, but it’s hard when you have a newborn, isn’t it? She’d even asked the lady cop that—“Do you have a baby?”—but the woman was looking at the beer cans piled up because each week they could only dump one small bin into the recycling which they shared with other tenants. Sure, there were cigarette butts on the table—but how was she supposed to tell John what to do? He was bigger and much stronger, and she relied on the money he got from scrapping. Like any woman she had to pick her battles—didn’t she? All those dumb tears still coming, she had tried to get those cops to understand. But none of it stopped them from looking at her like she was some kind of animal just choosing to live that way. And just like that they were taking him, and she was so weak, so tired—she hadn’t slept in days—she was almost handing him over. “I can’t—did I—give him to her?” she’d let slip out. Felt sick once she heard herself. But in that moment, with the cops looking right through her, she couldn’t even hear what they were saying, something about next steps and where, when—because she had slid down to the floor. Looking up, her baby held by some other woman now, she could feel herself rocking, the words they were saying and every other sound like the dog barking outside, the broken alarm still ringing in the hall, the kids playing next door, mixing together until everything was buzzing. She didn’t even care what John did to her when he got home—she wouldn’t even be able to feel it. Whatever he did, she felt she deserved it. “No one deserves that,” someone had said, and reached over, putting their hand on hers—and Brie looked back behind her at the people who’d just walked into the chapel, trying to remember who it’d been. Brie looked up at the clock again.
10:30
When the service started, the pastor said, “I’d like to ask, um, you—” and pointing to her he said, “the white lady. Right there. Yes. You. I know your name starts with a B—come on up, Bee, and say our prayer of thanksgiving.”
Brie wished he knew her name. The child in front of her had turned around and was staring, everything but her big brown eyes hidden by the back of the pew. She felt a tap on her shoulder.
“Yes, you, honey,” said a woman wearing a dark red hat, a big bow made of silk hanging off the side like a wilted flower. “Go on up.”
Brie looked back at her. “Oh, me?” she said. “Oh—okay.”
She walked slowly up to where the pastor stood, up on the pulpit. He squeezed her arms and said, “Go on, dear,” nodding toward the podium. There was no air-conditioning in the church, just these two metal fans spinning in the back; the twenty or so people in the pews were looking at her—some of the women were flapping their bulletins for air—anticipating what she was about to say like a glass of cold water. She swallowed.
“Good morning, church,” she said.
“Good morning!” they responded, echoing one another. When the little girl who sat up front with her grandma heard her own voice trailing behind in the air, she clasped her hand over her mouth. “Let us bow our heads,” Brie said, as she’d heard others do.
When Brie closed her eyes, she felt she was suddenly alone; but it was the kind of alone where she knew there were people about her, listening to her, watching her. Maybe even praying about her. The safe kind of alone.
“God . . . ,” she began, “thank you for bringing us here today.” She took a breath. “I especially want to thank you for my baby boy, James—” People said “Amen!” and she continued, “And thank you for waking me up this morning,” and others shouted, “Thank you!” So she continued, encouraged, “And thank you for this church family who have accepted me even though—even though I—” Her heart was racing. She felt lightheaded suddenly—sometimes the shame still turned her stomach. She started to feel sick—and maybe the woman in the red hat could tell, because she stood slowly to her feet and began singing, “I love to praise him! I love to praise his name. I love to praise him! I love to praise his name.” Brie was grateful for that, and soon she was clapping along as she walked back to her seat. “Good job,” Jayla whispered—she was another new church member—and Brie said, “Thank you.”
11:00
During testimonies Woody stood up quickly like he’d been waiting all day and thanked the church for helping him with his phone bill. “Love you guys,” he said. He was still homeless, but Brie was the only one in the church who knew. When Brie and John were out on the river near Woody’s camp, John always made fun of the way he stuttered, the way he smelled, but sometimes Woody walked Brie back from her job, which went from six to midnight, and which she’d had to give up since getting into this shelter. Another stood, said her family had been in a car accident, but God saw them through. When she sat back down, the woman started tearing up, wiping her eyes; Brie couldn’t help but cry with her from across the aisle. She reached out, held the woman’s hand. When the woman seemed to catch her breath, Brie felt it was her turn. She stood. “Today is my baby boy’s first birthday!” And at that the old woman plucked at the piano and the choir began singing, “Happy birthday to yuh, Happy birthday to yuh.” Brie danced a little in place. “Happy birthday!” And she continued, “And the people watching him are gonna bring him by so he can meet everyone!” At that they cheered like she just won something, and she felt that she had. But once the clapping ended, somewhere beneath that comforting, hard sound of hands smacking together was a melting, and she wished she hadn’t said anything at all. Her whole face—then her ears and her neck—flared up with heat, and she sat back down.
11:30
Even during the pastor’s message Brie kept checking her flip phone to see if she’d missed any calls. She wanted them to arrive before they did the part where they circled up and held hands; when someone was in the need of prayer, they got in the middle of that circle, and everyone laid hands on them. She and James both needed a whole lot of prayer; she couldn’t help but smile just thinking about the warmth that’d come over her if her church family put their hands on them.
Brie bit her nails, her cuticles already frayed pink, a couple of them bloody—something she did when she was nervous and something John hated. Stupid, she thought now. “So stupid,” she mumbled. Of course, they wouldn’t show.
Brie checked her phone again. The last thing she’d written was, “Will you please meet me outside?” and to that they’d never answered. She didn’t want them walking into the church with James. It was only right that she be the one holding James inside the church, that no one else be mistaken for his mother.
11:45
Outside, Brie hugged herself. What if he didn’t recognize her? What if he bent back toward the foster lady Sarah like she was the one who’d birthed him—whose body broke open for him? No, no, no. Of course, she felt bad for her—Sarah had shared with her that she’d never been able to have her own babies—but that didn’t change the truth.
He would recognize her. He’d know in the same way that her church family would know—where he belonged and who he belonged to.
Brie watched their car, glowing black in the sun, slow as it pulled to the curb.
When the car turned off, she was so lightheaded she worried she’d faint.
Sarah unbuckled James. As she took him out of his car seat, his face was turned the other way, toward Paul, the husband, who was sitting in the driver’s seat, his hands resting on the steering wheel like he was ready to pull away at any moment. He wouldn’t even look at Brie. She knew he never liked her.
“It’s okay, it’s okay,” Sarah was whispering into James’s ear. He was flushed pink from a nap. “Shh,” she said, “shhh,” when he started to cry a little. Brie wanted to say to that woman, Of course, it’s okay—he’ll be with his mother, but she knew not to say that by now. Her case manager was always telling her to stay calm—that they didn’t want her to prove anyone right, that she was “mentally unfit.” “But I don’t feel calm,” she’d explained, her leg shaking beneath the man’s desk. Part of her felt maybe he didn’t try hard enough—maybe because he didn’t think she deserved to get James back. Something about those meetings with him always left her angry. She even felt angry now, even as her baby was being handed over to her, even as she tucked her hands beneath his arms; even then she felt the impulse to pull him away from that woman, whose manicured nails hesitated before giving way. But she heard her case manager’s voice in her head—don’t prove them right, don’t show them you’re crazy (which is really what he meant, after all, wasn’t it?)—and tried to swallow all the anger down, tried, even, to smile at Sarah, her taut face quivering as she let go of James completely.
He’s not yours, Brie wanted to say. Stop crying, stupid.
When Brie began to walk away from them with James in her arms—faster when she felt him pulling away from her, reaching for that woman—Sarah called, “We’ll be waiting out here, okay?”
Brie didn’t respond. Her heart was beating so fast she couldn’t even imagine being able to speak. She felt in herself the desire to run, quick. First time she ran fast and hard, she was running from her mother; her father was right to call that woman a bitch, she felt now, thinking back on it, always going on and on about something or other—then it was just something she needed to do, run until her whole body was sparkling, until her mind was cleared of all those thoughts, those voices, until maybe one swam through it clear and shining, one thought she could grab and hold on to. Now, that thought was, Don’t. Look. Back.
12:00
“It’s me, it’s me, it’s me, O Lord,” they sang. “Standing in the need of prayer.” Holding James tight to her chest, Brie was in the middle of the circle, everyone’s voices rising and falling around them like waves. “Lord,” the pastor began, gathering the sound from deep in his belly, “we ask that you have mercy on your precious daughter here, Lord. And this beautiful child too, Lord.” Brie whispered, “James,” to the pastor. “—baby James, Lord. Protect them. Guide them!” Brie felt tingling heat from the hands on both of her shoulders, the top of her head, her elbows, and she was sure they were about to be healed, that their broken parts would be fused back together. “Keep the devil far from them!” His voice was like thunder and lightning, and James began to cry.
12:15
Brie felt the clock ticking, like the devil was sat right beside her waiting to grab him away. She’d have to hand him back to Sarah in thirty minutes. Maybe the people around her could see that devil there too, because it wasn’t one person who turned to her and said, “You’re okay, honey,” or “He looks just like you,” or “What pure joy he is,” but two or three. Brie wasn’t sure if the prayers had worked. She wished she’d felt it more, but when James had started to cry, she got distracted from the feeling and couldn’t settle him. And when she opened her eyes after the hands left her shoulders and back and head, one by one, like leaves falling from a tree, all these faces were still looking at them, but there was a sadness in their eyes that she did not like.
12:35
When the service ended and people came up to them and, putting a hand on her elbow, said, “We’re praying for you,” and “God has a plan—you remember that, okay?”—even the first lady, Miss Rhonda, who always looked like she was glowing from the inside, who seemed to float instead of walk even with that cane she used, kissed James on his head—but all Brie could think was, ten more minutes.
1:00
Alone in the chapel with her baby, Brie looked at the statue of Jesus. The purple silk draped over his shoulders looked like it hadn’t moved in years; in the filmy light from the window, Jesus’s head hung down, his gaze landing on the old, crusty carpet. Look at me, she wanted to say. Look at me.
But the pastor was always saying, “How can he hear you if you don’t say his name?”
So she said, “Look at me, Jesus,” her tongue burning when it touched her teeth. But she got nothing. Nothing. Nothing.
She considered the back door—she could slip out without anyone noticing, run fast down the alley. Make her way up Welton. Bang on the door of the shelter, her breath coursing like fire; she could hand James over to Sister Anna, close the door behind them, lock the dead bolt once and for all.
But instead of taking his son in his arms John would say, What did you do? Or maybe Sister Anna would say it first—her words sweet on the outside but Brie would know what she meant, that she needed to let go of him, that if she didn’t give him back, Sister Anna would call them herself; she’d tell the foster parents, her case manager, about what she did. He’s here, she might say in her soft voice, holding on to the phone in the office, her back turned to the door. Brie would be locked out. There wasn’t one person Brie could trust. Sister Anna might even agree with her case manager when he’d say that Brie was crazy, that he knew it all along.
No, no, no, Brie thought. That wouldn’t work. She just had to make do with what she had—just like always. Nothing had changed, had it? The fans whispered run, run, run, like the train she’d jumped up onto when she was sixteen, the metal step cutting her foot as her shoe fell off, but she didn’t even feel it, grabbed ahold of John’s hand, and got the hell out of that town. Nobody had stood up to her father—not even CPS—not even after she’d called them for the fourth time. One social worker visited twice, a cross hanging at her neck, but just left her there, with him. Because he was a cop, that’s why. Even her mother—even her own mother said she was the problem. Nobody stood up to her father until she met John. He was ten years older than she was and the first one to say anything. “You will never fucking touch her again,” he’d said, and they left. Just like that.
1:10
Why you always shaking? John would say if he saw her now. Why you always gotta be drunk? she’d say back. She pressed down on her leg with her left hand, forcing it still. But James didn’t like that. He writhed in her arms, letting his heavy head drop back. He’d gotten much stronger since she’d last seen him. She tried to wipe his tears with her scarf, but he kept pushing her away, like he didn’t even want to look at her, like he wanted anyone but her. “C’mon, sweet boy,” she said, whispering into his sweaty neck. “I just want to hold you a little longer.” But that didn’t help at all. He pushed her away, dragged his hand across her face, his little nails scraping her eyelid. “Ouch!” she said. “Don’t you know they’ll find us if you scream? Don’t you know they’ll take you from me?” His eyes got swollen pink; his cry got louder each time around like an alarm. “That’s what you want, isn’t it?” she heard herself mumble. “That’s what you always wanted.” The sound was inescapable—she’d had such a migraine that day he was taken; she’d just needed a little air! Now, when James took a breath, she could hear them; outside the chapel door, the pastor was saying something—she worried it was about her. She only realized she was cupping her hand over James’s mouth, barely touching his lips—he’d started screaming again and she’d needed to hear what the pastor was saying—when Sarah walked, then ran, into the chapel and cried out like someone had shot her in the gut.
Brie said, “I’m just trying to—” but the way the woman was reaching for him, looking at her with such disgust, such horror, made her hand him over without so much as a question. “I’m sorry!” she said. “I’m so sorry.”
1:30
Nothing came out but a yellow slime and bits of the dry doughnut she’d had earlier. She tried to catch her breath, laying her arm on the toilet seat. She let her forehead rest there. Her cries turned into moans, and that’s when she heard, “Brie?”
“She took him,” Brie said. “She took him from me.”
Jayla slid down to the floor, and Brie pushed open the stall door. Jayla grabbed some toilet paper and wiped the snot and tears from Brie’s face. “I understand,” she said, and Brie believed her. During the new members’ meeting, Jayla had told them how she used to be a man—at least on the outside—that only now she knew who she really was. Even if it meant she lost her job, even if her grandbaby, two years old now, had never even met her. Brie knew it was true, that Jayla knew herself. She was envious of that.
“Good as new,” Jayla said, when they both stood up and brushed themselves off. With her long, brown fingers, she combed Brie’s hair, which was really just a wig; Brie had started losing her hair, which was brown not blond, in her twenties; it was a condition she couldn’t even pronounce. That was another thing John liked to tease her about.
“Can we switch?” Brie found herself saying. She’d always wanted to see what she’d look like with dark red curls like Jayla had, but John only liked her as a blond. Jayla pulled off her wig, and suddenly her eyes looked so big Brie’s heart began to race looking into them. She’d never seen someone so up close. When she took off her own wig, Brie watched Jayla’s face brighten, like they were girls trading secrets. They held them out to one another, and because there was no mirror in the bathroom, they used each other, combing out the flyaways with their fingers. Jayla took Brie’s face in both hands and said, “There. Perfect.”
5:30
Brie hadn’t wanted to go back to the shelter, so she’d just walked for hours. But it was almost time for dinner; she headed up the stairs, trying to calm down. When she opened the door, John was stretched across the bed, sleeping with his mouth open.
She put her hand on him, shook him gently. “C’mon, John. Dinner.”
“Leave me alone,” he said. Beside the bed was a bottle, vodka that didn’t show on his breath. There had been a couple of times Brie had felt like telling on him—but, of course, she didn’t. “You’re drunk,” she said.
“Fuck off.” He pulled the covers over his head. “Shut those blinds.”
Maybe it was something about that warm light, like maybe God was coming through that window, turning the pale wood floor pink, maybe it was because she knew there’d be consequences for how she’d not given James back at the agreed time, that she had nothing to lose now, that made her say, “You know, three strikes and we’re out, John. Remember?” They’d been warned the last time John came in drunk, stumbling around like a fool. Sister Anna had pulled Brie aside, into the office, sat her down, said, “Brie, you’re welcome to stay—that will be your choice. But if he comes home drunk again, he will be asked to leave. Do you understand?”
“You know, John,” she said. “It’s my choice . . . Do you even get that?”
“What?” he said, squinting at her. She knew she was just talking crap now, her body ringing, beginning to itch the way it did when she got nervous, when her thoughts started slipping one into another.
“Nothing,” she said. She set her bag down. “Just get up.”
“No,” he said, coughing—and she couldn’t stand the sound of it. Couldn’t stand the smell either, the whole room reeking of him.
Brie stood at the foot of the bed, with her hands on her hips. “They’re not gonna believe me when I tell them you can’t come down for dinner—they’re gonna ask me questions.”
“I don’t give a fuck, Brie. Get out.”
“I’m so sick of answering questions for you, John,” she said. “I’m so sick of it!”
She sighed as loud as she could, turning for the door.
“Get out!” he yelled.
Her hand on the doorknob, she bit her lip. She’d make something up. Say he had the flu and shouldn’t be around other people. But it wasn’t even flu season. They’d look at her like she was a liar, tell her to go tell him to come down anyway—only way there was going to be a sense of trust in the house, Sister Anna would say. Only way they’d be a community. She’d heard it again and again.
“No,” she said. “I won’t. And you know what, John? I saw James today. Did you even remember it was his birthday? Do you even care? Sarah brought him to my church and let me be with him all afternoon. I got to squeeze and hug and kiss him. And you didn’t.”
John sat up, the blankets sliding off the bed. It was a mismatched collection of things—a couple of ratty pillows and sheets with torn edges and holes in them. It drove her nuts that none of it matched. She started to pick them up and throw them back onto the bed. The edge of a sheet whipped John’s face—had she meant to do it?—and he got inches away. “And you didn’t tell me?” he said, looking down at her, his spit landing on the bridge of her nose. He rubbed his eye with the back of his hand. Blinked.
“Gross,” she said, wiping his spit off. “Why do you think I didn’t tell you?”
“You don’t want me to see our son,” he said. He wiped his eyes, red and watery, again.
“You being drunk around him is the last thing we need. You think they’d ever give him back to us if you showed up for a visit drunk?” Brie felt herself grow taller as she spoke—“Not if I can help it,” she said. “I will not let you ruin that for me.”
When someone started knocking on the door, she was watching blood dripping from her nose onto her skirt. John’s back was turned toward her. He was sitting on the other side of the bed, the farthest he could get from her in that room. His head was in his hands. Maybe he was crying. She didn’t care.
“Brie? Are you okay? I heard something fall,” Sister Anna said. “John, open this door!”
When he did, he sat back down, turned away like a child in trouble. Then Sister Anna was wiping Brie’s face with her soft T-shirt. She smelled like baby oil, like James after a bath.
“She fainted,” John said. “It’s been happening a lot. I don’t know what’s wrong with her.”
“You need to leave,” she said to John. “Now.”
John started, “But, she—”
“Now. I’ll bag your things up and put them outside for you by morning—you can come and get them. But you are no longer welcome here.”
Brie heard him walking down the stairs. She heard the door close behind him, the bells on the back of it ringing when he slammed it. She knew Sister Anna, who was in her seventies or eighties, followed him down, walking slowly, calmly. Brie hoped someone would lock the door behind him—something she’d always been too scared to do. “Don’t you ever lock me out,” he’d said to her once. She got to her feet slowly, pressing the top of her hand to her nose. She held on to the banister of the staircase, made her way down a couple of steps. “Lock the door!” she yelled. And again, letting the animal in her out, she roared, “Lock the door!”
6:00
In the bathroom her wig was tilted, sliding off her head with each second. As she leaned over the sink, dabbing water on her mouth, she let it fall off. Left it there on the floor. In the mirror her eyes pulsed. Her whole body, each part of it, was alive, and she started to see who she really was. But maybe she wasn’t ready yet, so she walked down the hall. In one bedroom she knew three people slept in one bed, the mom and her kids, and the dad slept on a few blankets piled up on the floor. One of their boys used a wheelchair—they had to carry him up and down the stairs—kept it in the living room by the piano. In another room was a woman who only wore leopard print, who they could sometimes hear crying in there, screaming through the walls, “You don’t know what it’s like to be me!”
As Brie walked down the stairs, she had to catch herself, her legs almost giving out—something fluttered in her chest, a hummingbird trapped.
She stood at the doorway of the dining room where the other guests were sat, waiting.
“You’re late,” one of them said. She’d cooked that night. “The food’s cold now.”
The others looked at her, without surprise, without pity. They’d known all along.
“Here,” the new girl said, putting her hand on the chair beside her. Cassie was maybe ten years younger than Brie. She’d just gotten out of jail, and she was eight months pregnant. “Sit by me.” The night before, she’d told Brie that it felt wrong that her boyfriend hadn’t been arrested too. After all, he was taking the money she made. “That’s what a pimp does, right?” Brie wasn’t sure what to tell her then. Now she said, “Do you ever sing to your baby? I did. I think that helps the baby to know you, to know your voice before anyone else’s. That’s important. I can teach you the song I used to sing if you want.” Finally, only then, she remembered how it went.
“John is not allowed to step foot in this house again,” Sister Anna said, soft as a prayer, after she sat down at the table. Brie knew that she meant it too; she wished she had a stronger faith sometimes—a faith like that. She looked at the meal before her, inhaled deep. “This looks good,” she said, looking at the lump of brown meat on the platter before her. “What is it?” But the other nun cleared her throat—reminding Brie they always took a moment of silence before they ate. “Oh,” she said. “Sorry.” The eyes closed around her, one by one, like lights in a house. The only one who didn’t close her eyes was the young couple’s baby; sat in her high chair at the head of the table, she was about Jame’s age. Her eyes were still shining with old tears. She stared at Brie, her mouth open. Poor thing always had a cold. Brie stared back for a moment, at her blue eyes, her black eyelashes, heavy on her raw cheeks. Brie tasted something. She quickly wiped the blood off her lip, looking away from the baby, and for a moment, she was glad they took James when they did. Before he could really see—could understand. “Close your eyes,” Brie whispered without looking back at her. “Pray.”
